Wayback Burgers: A Bold New Burger Joint Near You

In the crowded arena of fast-casual dining, Wayback Burgers aims to carve out its niche by offering a nostalgic take on the classic American burger joint experience. With its roots dating back to 1991, the chain takes pride in it’s tried and true “made-to-order” burgers, “hand-dipped” milkshakes, and a guarantee of freshness. However, while the restaurant succeeds in several areas, it also slips in ways that may leave more critical customers questioning its somewhat elevated price point.

Ambience and Atmosphere: Entering Wayback Burgers, you are greeted by a hybrid of retro diner aesthetics, similar to a mom-and-pop shop, with it’s open counters and obscure shape, and the familiar air of a modern fast-casual restaurant, like Shake Shack, or Five Guys. The decor is clean and minimalist, though a bit boring, lacking the distinct charm one might expect from a place hoping to evoke nostalgia from its patrons. However, I believe this is because the restaurant was very recently opened, and the staff may not have had time to spice up the place as much as they’d like to. The setting is comfortable but far from remarkable. For a chain that nods to the golden age of American diners, a stronger visual identity could improve the dining experience.

Burger Quality: The main attraction at Wayback is, unsurprisingly, their burgers. I tried the “Wayback Classic,” a double-patty cheeseburger layered with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and their signature special sauce. The first bite delivered on the promise of fresh, flavorful beef—juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked to order. The balance between the toppings was commendable; the crunch of the lettuce and pickle slices paired well with the creaminess of the sauce. However, while the burger started strong, structural issues soon emerged.

The generous portion of sauce, while flavorful, somewhat overwhelmed the structure of the sandwich, leading to a slightly messy dining experience. Some argue that a little mess is part of the burger-eating experience, and I usually find myself agreeing with that idea, such as in the case of Wayback. There is a fine line between a satisfyingly juicy burger and one that requires constant attention to keep intact. Fortunately, this burger stayed on the right side.

Sides and Extras: Sides are often looked over at burger joints, but they can enhance or detract from the overall meal in significant ways. The fries and cheese at Wayback were forgettable. With a crispy exterior and a fluffy interior, they slightly lacked the seasoning to stand out in a competitive fast-food market. However, in my eyes, this is part of the image Wayback is trying to achieve with its audience: a cozy burger joint that may not beat Gordon Ramsey, but provides a comforting meal to either start or end your day. The onion rings were a pleasant surprise—crispy without being overly greasy, with a subtle sweetness in the batter that paired well with the savory burger.

The true star of the show, however, was the milkshake. I was enraptured by the Oreo Mud Pie milkshake, and it did not disappoint. Thick, creamy, and packed with flavor, this shake struck the perfect balance between indulgence and refreshment. It was clear that, unlike the fries, the milkshake is a cornerstone at Wayback, and one that delivers.

Service and Experience: Service at Wayback Burgers is what one might expect from your average chain—efficient, polite, but not overly attentive. The staff was friendly, though there was little interaction beyond the transaction at the counter. The food arrived within a somewhat concerning time frame. In an era where fast-casual dining thrives on the strength of its hospitality and service experience, Wayback might benefit from investing in a more engaged approach to customer interaction. On the other hand, the lack of conversation with staff opened the window for me to talk to my family along with some other customers about our day, as well as the happenings of Westborough, strengthening the sense of community provided by the dining experience.

Value for Money: Perhaps the most significant point of Wayback Burgers lies in its pricing. While the chain positions itself as a step above traditional fast food, the higher price point raises expectations. When compared to other premium burger options, the value doesn’t quite match up. A burger, fries, and milkshake combo (including tax) can easily run for somewhere around $14 to $20, which might feel steep given the occasional mistakes in quality and presentation. For that price, one might expect a more refined dining experience, or at least more consistency in execution. Then again, going back to my earlier point, Wayback isn’t trying to be the golden standard in the restaurant business.

Final Verdict: Wayback Burgers undoubtedly excels in a few key areas—the beef is of good quality, and the milkshakes are a highlight—but there are aspects that could use some sharpening. The dining experience feels slightly incomplete, with certain elements falling short of expectations for a chain with almost premium pricing. While the restaurant is certainly a level above the most generic fast food, it may not yet have found the right balance between nostalgic charm, modern appeal, and the level of execution that would justify its cost. However, the restaurant is noticeably new, and any mistakes found on my run are more probably going to go through an ironing out process led by the manager(s), just as any other store or service might do.

For casual burger enthusiasts and less enthusiastic townspeople alike, Wayback offers a satisfying meal.

Rating: 8/10

Alternative: 3.9 to 4.1/5